 | William Oldnall Russell - 1824 - 594 sider
...such a person be capable in other respects of distinguishing right from [* 17] wrong, *there would be no excuse for any act of atrocity which he might commit under this description of derangement (и). Had6eld's James Hadfield was tried in Westminster Hall, in the year 1800, before a special commission,... | |
 | Theodric Romeyn Beck - 1825 - 696 sider
...gratifying revenge by some hostile act. If such a person were capable, in other respects, of distinguishing right from wrong, there was no excuse for any act...might commit under this description of derangement." t By these principles, the criminal jurisprudence of England and this country has been guided, and... | |
 | William Oldnall Russell - 1826 - 788 sider
...act, if such a person be capable in other respects of distinguishing right from wrong, there would be no excuse for any act of atrocity which he might commit under this description of derangement, (и) James Hadfield was tried in the Court of King's Bench, in the year 1800, on an indictment for... | |
 | Leonard Shelford - 1833 - 964 sider
...act, if such person be capable in other respects of distinguishing right from wrong, there would be no excuse for any act of atrocity which he might commit under this description of derangement (e). The prisoner was found guilty, and executed. James Hadfield was tried in the Court of King's Bench,... | |
 | Frederick Augustus Carrington, Great Britain. Court of King's Bench, Joseph Payne - 1833 - 668 sider
...act, if such a person be capable in other respects of distinguishing right from wrong, there would be no excuse for any act of atrocity which he might commit under this description of derangement." HOME WINTER CIRCUIT. 1831. 1831. Dec. 8th. An indictment for manslaughter charged, that A. gave to... | |
 | I. RAY, M.D. - 1838
...by some hostile act, he says, " if such a person were capable, in other respects, of distinguishing right from wrong, there was no excuse for any act...might commit under this description of derangement." ~ Mr. Russell, in his work on criminal law, includes inability to distinguish right from wrong 1 1... | |
 | Richard Clarke Sewell - 1843 - 406 sider
...revenge by some hostile act. If ' such a person were capable, in other respects, of ' distinguishing right from wrong, there was no ' excuse for any act...which he might ' commit under this description of derangement."(o) In Oxford's case for shooting at the Queen, the Direction to question left to the... | |
 | Daniel MACNAUGHTON - 1843 - 96 sider
...gratifying revenge by some hostile act. If such a person were capable in other respects of distinguishing right from wrong, there was no excuse for any act of atrocity which he might commit under the description of insanity." Now, from the last observation of the learned judge who tried that cause,... | |
 | 1844 - 510 sider
...act, if such a person be capable in other respects of distinguishing right from wrong, there would be no excuse for any act of atrocity which he might commit under this description of derangement. These early cases have thus been referred to in detail, because they contain the true doctrine upon... | |
 | 1848 - 738 sider
...gratifying revenge by some hostile act. If such a person were capable, in other respects, of distinguishing right from wrong, there was no excuse for any act...might commit under this description of derangement." On the trial of Hadfield, mentioned above, it was contended by Mr. Erskine, on behalf of the prisoner,... | |
| |
There was a third species of insanity, in which the patient fancied the existence of injury, and sought an opportunity of gratifying revenge by some hostile act. If such a person was capable, in other respects, of distinguishing right from wrong, there... 
