PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed; ground stated in journal entry. It is ordered and adjudged by this court that the judgment of the said circuit court be, and the same hereby is, reversed; and this court, proceeding to render the judgment which the circuit court should have rendered, reverses the judgment of the court of common pleas, and grants a new trial on the grounds: (1) That the court of common pleas erred in the charge to the jury as found commencing at the bottom of page 91 of the printed record, and consisting of the entire paragraph ending in the middle of page 92 of said record; (2) and in refusing to submit the special request made by plaintiff in error, found on page 95 of the printed record. It is further considered by this court that plaintiff in error recover of defendant in error the costs of the plaintiff in error made in this and the circuit court, to be taxed, and this cause is remanded to the court of common pleas for a new trial and further proceedings according to law. SHAUCK, C. J., and PRICE, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., concur. NATIONAL BISCUIT CO. et al. v. DOUGLASS et al. (No. 9,494.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. June 5, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Richland County. Jenner & Weldon, for plaintiffs in error. Donnell, Marriott & Bissman, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. NEWPORT & C. BRIDGE CO. v. JUTTE et al. (No. 9,534.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. March 6, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. Robert Ramsey, W. W. Ramsey, and Maxwell & Ramsey, for plaintiff in error. Stephens, Lincoln'& Stephens, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., and PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, SPEAR, and DAVIS, JJ., concur. NEW YORK, C. & ST. L. RY. CO. v. ROE, (No. 8,801.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 19, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Huron County. J. H. Clarke and C. P. & L. W. Wickham, for plaintiff in error. Jesse Vickery, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, CREW, and SUMMERS, JJ., con cur. NICHOLS v. STATE. (No. 9,824.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. May 8, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Wyandot County. Finley & Gallinger, for plaintiff in error. H. H. Newell, Pros. Atty., W. B. Wheeler, and Boyd P. Doty, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., and CREW, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., concur. NORTH v. COBLENTZ et al. (No. 9,522.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. May 22, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Darke County. A. A. North and S. V. Hartman, for plaintiff in error. Anderson, Bowman & Anderson and Robeson & Yount, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., and CREW and SPEAR, JJ., concur. NORTH et al. v. RUMMELL et al. (No. 9,421.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 30, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Darke County. A. A. North and W. Y. Stubbs, for plaintiffs in error. Robeson & Yount, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and PRICE and SUMMERS, JJ., concur. NORTHERN OHIO TRACTION CO. v. MITCHELL. (No. 9,330.) Supreme Court of Ohio. April 24, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Summit County. Rogers, Rowley, Bradley & Rockwell, for plaintiff in error. Billman & Billman and Orlando Wilcox, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., con cur. NORTHWESTERN NAT. LIFE INS. CO. v. HARE. (No. 8.984.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. April 3, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, PITTS v. SWIGART. (No. 9,281.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Oct. 24, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Richland County. Maguire & Galbraith and Samuel Marriott, for plaintiff in error. O. M. Farber and Douglass & Mengert, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. PITTSBURGH, C., C. & ST. L. RY. CO. v. FAGIN. (No. 9,404.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. May 1, 1906.) Error to Superior Court of Cincinnati. Maxwell & Ramsey and W. W. Ramsey, for plaintiff in error. Charles W. Baker, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., con cur. PITTSBURGH, C., C. & ST. L. RY. CO. v. HERZOG et al. (No. 8,945.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. March 6, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Lucas County. Maxwell & Ramsey, for plaintiff in error. Coffey, Mallon, Mills & Vordenberg and Cabell & Freiberg, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, SPEAR, and DAVIS, JJ., concur. PITTSBURGH, C., C. & ST. L. RY. CO. v. MAHON. (No. 9,396.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 23, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court. Tuscarawas County. Dunbar & Sweeney and T. D. Healea, for plaintiff in error. D. A. Hollingsworth and T. H. Loller, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed, and that of the court of common pleas affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. ton and Follett & Follett, for plaintiff in error. PROVIDENT SAVINGS LIFE ASSUR. SOC. v. LODGE. (No. 9,316.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 5, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Cuyahoga County. Garfield, Howe & Westenhaver, for plaintiff in error. Hamilton, Hamilton & Smith, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., con cur. PRUDENTIAL INS. CO. OF AMERICA v. MULLER. (No. 9,481.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 20, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. A. C. Shattuck, for plaintiff in error. Bates & Meyer, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., con cur. RANK v. EVANS. (No. 9,529.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. May 15, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Licking County. Hunter & Hunter and Smythe & Smythe, for plaintiff in error. Flory & Flory and G. C. Daugherty, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., con cur. RAUB et al. v. ARREL'S EX'R. (No. 9,353.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 19, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Mahoning County. Norris, Jackson & Rose, for plaintiffs in error. Arrel, McVey, Rowland & Harrington, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. RICE et al. v. COLVILLE. (No. 9,292.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Oct. 31, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Knox County. F. V. Owen and Waight & Moore, for plaintiff in error. F. O. Levering and L. B. Houck, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. ROBERTS et al. v. TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES OF XENIA TP. (Nos. 8,863, 8,864.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 16, 1906.) Er ror to Circuit Court, Greene County. M. J. Hartley, for plaintiffs in error. Gowdy & Doug las, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgments affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, and CREW, JJ., concur. SUMMERS, J., not participating. SPEAR, J., dissents. ROBINSON et al. v. JOINT BOARD OF COM'RS OF PUTNAM AND HANCOCK COUNTIES et al. (No. 9,644.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. June 26, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Putnam County. Bailey & Bailey, for plaintiffs in error. Risser & Smith, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PRICE, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., co cur. SIMS, Treasurer. v. RIESER et al. (No. 9,243.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Oct. 17, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Franklin County. Butler, Weinland & Marshall, for plaintiff in error. C. T. Clark and O. H. Mosier, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, CREW, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. SINGER MFG. CO. v. COMMERCIAL NAT. BANK. (No. 9,304.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 14, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Marion County. W. O. Henderson and Mouser & Quigley for plaintiff in error. Carey & Parker and J. F. & L. B. McNeal, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment of the circuit court reversed, and that of the common pleas court affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. SMART v. MASTERS & WARDENS OF NOVA CEASAREA HARMONY LODGE, NO. 2. (No. 9,361.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 22, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Cuyahoga County. McMillin & Ingersoll, for plaintiff in error. Hamilton, Hamilton & Smith, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. SMITH V. BOARD OF COM'RS OF WILLIAMS COUNTY. (No. 9.384.) Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 27, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Williams County. L. E. Griffin and Chauncey L. Newcomer, for plaintiff in error. Edward Gaudern and Charles A. Bowersox, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J.. and CREW, SUMMERS, and DAVIS, JJ., concur. SMITH et al. v. GOODWIN. (No. 8.804.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 19, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Columbiana County. P. M. & A. G. Smith, for plaintiffs in error. Potts & Wells and C. S. Speaker, for defendants in er ror. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. SMITH v. HOCKING VALLEY RY. CO. (No. 8,697.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 14, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Franklin Countr. J. C. Nicholson, for plaintiff in error. C. O. Hunter, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, CREW, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. SMITH et al. v. KENT et al. (No. 8,803.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 19, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Columbiana County. P. M. & A. G. Smith, for plaintiffs in error. Potts & Wells and C. S. Speaker, for defendants in er ror. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J.. and SHAUCK, PRICE, CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. 78 N.E.-72 SMITH v. PITTSBURG, C., C. & ST. L. RY. CO. et al. (No. 9,323.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 16, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. Matthews & Merrell, for plaintiff in error. Maxwell & Ramsey, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and PRICE, CREW. and SUMMERS, JJ., concur. SMITH et al. v. UNION SAVINGS BANK & TRUST CO. (No. 9,207.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. May 22, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. C. W. Baker and O'Hara & Jordan, for plaintiffs in error. W. H. Mackoy, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., and CREW, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. SOUTHARD v. MOSGROVE et al. (No. 9.311.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 21, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Champaign County. S. V. Hartman and Warnock & Eichelberger, for plaintiff in error. L. D. Johnson and T. F. Frank, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, CREW, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. SPRINGFIELD FIRE & MARINE INS. CO. v. WAGNER. (No. 9.325.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. April 24, 1906.) Error to Circuit Court, Seneca County. J. W. Monney and Willis Bacon, for plaintiff in error. Platt & Black and G. B. Keppel, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed; grounds stated in journal entry. It is ordered and adjudged by this court that the judgment of said circuit court be, and the same hereby is, reversed for error in affirming the judgment of the court of common pleas of said Seneca county, and the judgment of said court of common pleas is reversed for error in overruling the motion for a new trial on the grounds that the court erred in the admission of evidence, in refusing to charge, and in its general charge to the jury; it appearing from the plaintiff's evidence that Lillis, the mortgagee, is a real and not a fictitious person, he is a necessary party to the action, or a valid release of the mortgage must be proven. It appearing from the plaintiff's evidence that the mortgagee neither signed the release nor authorized it, it was error to admit in evidence the release on the mortgage record. The verdict is set aside, and the case is remanded to the said court of common pleas for a new trial. SHAUCK, C. J., and CREW, SUMMERS, SPEAR, and DAVIS, JJ., concur. SPYKER et al. v. BOARD OF EDUCATION OF LIMA SCHOOL DIST. (No. 8.786.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 12, 1905.) Error to Circuit Court, Allen County. Sprague & Lippincott, C. B. Adgate, and D. C. Henderson, for plaintiffs in error. Richie & Richie, Motter, Mackenzie & Weadock, and Wheeler & Bentley, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. DAVIS, C. J., and SHAUCK, PRICE, SUMMERS, and SPEAR, JJ., concur. STANDARD LIFE & ACCIDENT INS. CO. v. SAYLER et al. (No. 9,225.) (Supreme Court of Ohio, Oct. 10, 1905.) Error to Superior Court of Cincinnati. Robertson & Buch |