REPORTS

OF

CIVIL AND CRIMINAL CASES

DECIDED BY THE

COURT OF APPEALS

OF KENTUCKY.

VOLUME XXII.

T. R. McBEATH, Reporter.

VOLUME 129, KENTUCKY REPORTS.

Containing Cases Decided from May 8, to Dec. 15, 1908.

95

LEXINGTON, ky.

JAMES E. HUGHES, PRINTER AND BINDER

1909.

OCT 26 1909

JUDICIAL OFFICERS OF THE STATE

COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY

(As constituted during the period covered by this volume-1908.)

Hon. ED. C. O'REAR, Chief Justice.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

Hon. W. E. SETTLE,

Hon. T. J. NUNN,

Hon. HENRY S. BARKER,

Hon. JOHN M. LASSING,

Hon. JOHN D. CARROLL,
Hon. J. P. HOBSON,

Hon. WM. ROGERS CLAY, Commissioner.

(As constituted now-1909.)

Hon. W. E. SETTLE, Chief Justice.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

Hon. T. J. NUNN,

Hon. HENRY S. BARKER,
Hon. JOHN M. LASSING,
Hon. JOHN D. CARROLL,

Hon. J. P. HOBSON,

Hon. ED. C. O'REAR,

Hon. WM. ROGERS CLAY, Commissioner.

OFFICERS OF THE COURT, 1909.

JAMES BREATHITT, Attorney General,

JOHN F. LOCKETT, Assistant Attorney General,
TOM B. MCGREGOR, Assistant Attorney General.
THEO. B. BLAKEY, Assistant Attorney General,
NAPIER ADAMS, Clerk,

C. S. WILSON, Deputy Clerk,

FRANK K. KAVANAUGH, Librarian,

T. R. McBEATH, Reporter.

(During the period covered by this volume.)

Bardwell

.Paducah

...Murray

Madisonville

1st District-R. J. BUGG

2nd District-W. M. REED

3rd District THOS. P. COOK

4th District-J. F. GORDON

5th District-J. W. HENSON 6th District-T. F. BIRKHEAD 7th District-W. P. SANDIDGE

8th District-JOHN M. GALLOWAY

9th District-WEED S. CHELF
10th District-S. E. JONES
11th District-I. H. THURMAN
12th District-C. C. MARSHALL
15th District-W. C. BELL
14th District-R. L. STOUT
15th District-J. W. CAMMACK
16th District-W. McD. SHAW
16th District-M. L. HARBESON
17th District-J. W. YUNGBLUT
18th District-L. P. FRYER

19th District-JAS. P. HARBESON
20th District-S. G. KINNER
21st District-ALLIE W. YOUNG
22nd District-WATTS PARKER
23rd District-J. P. ADAMS
24th District-A. J. KIRK

25th District-J. M. BENTON
26th District-A. J. MOSS

27th District-H. C. FAULKNER

28th District-M. L. JARVIS

29th District-H. C. BAKER

30th District-Jefferson Circuit Court-Louisville

JOSEPH PRYOR, Criminal Branch.

SHACKELFORD MILLER, Chancery Branch, First Division.
SAMUEL B. KIRBY, Chancery Branch, Second Division.
EMMET FIELD, Common Pleas Branch, First Division.

THOS. F. GORDON, Common Pleas Branch, Second Division. MATT O'DOHERTY, Common Pleas Branch, Third Division. 31st District-D. W. GARDNER

.Salyersville

32nd District-J. B. HANNAH 33rd District-L. D. LEWIS

...Dixon

Owensboro .Russellville

.Bowling Green

.Elizabethtown

...Glasgow

.Springfield

Shelbyville

.Harrodsburg
Versailles

. Owenton Covington . Covington .Newport

. Cynthiana

Flemingsburg
Catlettsburg

.Morehead

.Lexington

Beattyville

.Paintsville

Winchester . Pineville

Barboursville

.Somerset .Columbia

.Sandy Hook
.Hyden

COMMONWEALTH ATTORNEYS

(During the period covered by this volume.)

1st District-W. H. HESTER
2nd District-JOHN G. LOVETT
3rd District-DENNY P. SMITH
4th District-JNO. L. GRAYOT
5th District-S. V. DIXON
6th District-BEN D. RINGO
7th District-R. Y. THOMAS, Jr.,.
8th District-NAT T. HOWARD

9th District-J. R. LAYMAN

10th District-D. A. MCCANDLESS
11th District-R. L. DURHAM

12th District-CHAS. H. SANDFORD
13th District-CHAS. A. HARDIN
14th District-ROBT. B. FRANKLIN
15th District-FRANK C. GREEN
16th District-L. T. APPLEGATE
17th District-W. A. BURKAMP
18th District-JAS. C. DEDMAN
19th District-M. J. HENNESSEY
20th District-J. B. WILHOIT
21st District-ALEX CONNER
22nd District-JNO. R. ALLEN
23rd District-KELLY CASH
24th District-JOHN F. BUTLER
25th District-B. A. CRUTCHER
26th District-J. B. SNYDER
27th District-WM. LEWIS

28th District-B. J. BETHURUM
29th District-A. A. HUDDLESTON
30th District-JOS. M. HUFFAKER

31st District-W. H. MAY

32nd District-J. M. WAUGH 33rd District-IRA FIELDS