throughout the whole evening, not easily to have been exceeded.'

pp. 286—291.

pp. 92.

Art. VII. 1. Wages or the Whip. An Essay on the Comparative

Cost and Productiveness of Free and Slave Labour. By Josiah Conder, Author of “ The Modern Traveller ”, “ Italy", &c. 8vo.

Price 2s. 6d. London, 1833. 2. A Vindication of a Loan of £15,000,000 to the West India

Planters, shewing that it may not only be lent with perfect safety but with immense advantage both to the West Indians and to the

people of England. By James Cropper. 8vo. Price 6d. 3. A Letter from Legion to the Right Hon. E. G. Stanley, fc. &c. &c.

Secretary of State for the Colonies, upon his Scheme for the Abo

lition of Colonial Slavery. 8vo. pp. 32. Price ls. London, 1833. OF the first of these pamphlets we shall say nothing more than

that it comprises a mass of documentary evidence abundantly attesting the correctness of the proposition, that Slavery is a political blunder. Slave labour is shewn to be dearer in its prime cost, dearer from its inferior productiveness, dearer from the waste and bad economy to which it uniformly leads, dearer from the capital sunk, and dearer from the state expenditure which it entails. The enormous expense of uncertain profits of cultivation by slave labour are shewn to be, according to the highest authorities, from Bryan Edwards down to Earl Belmore, the main cause of the present distressed state of the planters. And finally, the practicability of securing a regular supply of free labour in the sugar colonies is established by facts drawn from official documents and other sources, relating to the effects of emancipation on manumitted negroes, and to the success with which plantations are worked by free labour in the Spanish colonies. Slavery, however, it is remarked, must be abolished, with the burdens it entails before the motive to employ the cheaper labour of the freeman or to economize the dear labour of the slave, can come into operation. No plan of emancipation can be either effective or safe that is not of a decisive character.

• It must not attempt to combine the two opposite and incompatible systems of free and slave labour. It must not superadd the cost of free labour to the waste and burden of slavery. It must not destroy coercion, by a plan which supplies no motives for labour ; which precludes alike the stimulus of competition, the sense of gratitude, or the immediate prospect of advantage. It must not detain upon the plantations that redundant portion of labour which might be altogether economized by a better system. It must not continue to hang a dead weight upon the elastic springs of human industry, while the machinery is yet expected to work without embarrassment. The substitution of free labour for bond labour of every description can alone indemnify the planter for the loss of his living capital, and redeem him from the effect of the standing economical blunder in which he has so long and so fatally persisted. Slavery must be abolished. Its total abolition will carry compensation with it. Any thing short of entire and immediate emancipation will fail of its object; will be ruinous to the planter, unjust to the slave, unsafe to the colonies, and, in a word, not merely impolitic, but impracticable.'

Mr. Cropper takes a similar view of the necessity of a total abolition of slavery in order to the realizing of any of the advantages to be derived from the proposed loan; but slavery being abolished, he proves by the logic of arithmetical calculations, that the advance may be made without hazard, and with great benefit to all parties, which is designed to relieve the planter from his present embarrassments, and to enable him to disentangle himself at once from the expenses of slavery and of his commercial bondage. Mr. Cropper has shewn, that what would be saved to this country by the abolition of slavery, with the burdens it entails, would enable Government to deal liberally with the West India Colonists.

Mr. Stanley's plan of emancipation is an ingenious one ; and twenty years ago it might have been possible to make the experiment he proposes; although, in the working, it would assuredly have failed. In the present state of things, it would be alike perilous and impracticable. 'It is founded, as the Author of the Letter from Legion remarks, on two propositions, each of which

is self contradictory in its enunciation, and iniquitous in its operation. 1. The slave is entitled to his freedom, and there'fore he shall redeem himself. 2. The slave is unfitted, by long • and brutal coercion, for the discharge of spontaneous labour, and

therefore, for twelve years to come, he shall be compelled to ' three parts of his labour by coercive means.' With legal acuteness, this Writer, who is generally understood to be the son of the late distinguished philanthropist James Stephen, Esq. dissects the ministerial plan, and exposes its illusive, crude, unjust, and visionary character. Even the best, because the most specific part of the plan, the liberation of the children, is shewn to be open to fatal objections, the very principle of the condition with which it is encumbered being unjust and cruel.

Slavery is offered as the alternative of maintaining them, when the very means of maintenance are taken away. Ex hypothesi the parent's wages must be accumulated to redeem his own freedom. If he takes one sixpence from the sacred hoard, his own emancipation is deferred. All the time which can reasonably be exacted for labour through the day, is appropriated to his master, or to his own redemption. Yet you most ingeniously propose that he shall find means to clothe and feed his child, under the penalty of exposing that child to a longer bondage than himself! Is it not cruel, is it not unnatural, to create this distressing competition between paternal affection and selfish interest? You do not even propose that the child shall receive wages ; if this is intended, and on the same scale of proportion between his value and his time, why is his servitude to be of longer duration than his parents? To be consistent it should be less, because if his tender years admit of education in moral habits with greater certainty, he need not serve so long a noviciate to qualify him for the rights of citizenship; the only reason that you assign for the long apprenticeship of the adult. But there are other yet more serious objections to this part of the scheme. In the first place you know, or ought to know, that in the case of plantation slaves, the father of the child is too often unknown even to its mother; nor is the relation more likely to be acknowledged when it entails with it a pecuniary burthen, and a serious personal sacrifice; the option, therefore, which you give, serves very well to cheat the superficial enquirer into an acquiescence in the reasonableness of an infant apprenticeship, but in fact it will but rarely furnish a solid hope of redeeming the poor child from his eighteen years of servitude. It would have been more honest to have enacted at once, that all children shall be apprenticed to the age of 20 or 24, for such must be the case at least nine times out of ten. I hate this artful cloaking of a general rule in the guise of an exception. The general rule will be the 18 years of servitude-the parental maintenance will be the exception ; and this should have been the honest avowal made to the anti-slavery party. They have lately heard enough of infant slavery to comprehend its meaning. I suspect that on second thoughts, they will scarcely hail with much satisfaction this threatened emigration of it to our colonies.

* But again: you cannot but be aware that one of the most offensive and intolerable of all the incidents of slavery, is the subjection of young females to the power of their owners. Is your long apprenticeship likely to remove this evil? Will it diminish opportunity, or restrict the power of compulsion ? I will not say that it will have the contrary effect, but it appears to me most likely to leave matters exactly where they were.'

The scheme of apprenticed labour must be abandoned. Where it has been tried, as at the Cape Colony, it has been found alike oppressive and unprofitable. The West India proprietors are beginning to perceive, that if the cry for the abolition of slavery is to prevail, it will be for their own interest to consent to immediate and total abolition, rather to any half measures. To them, the compromise proposed would be ruinous, since it would well nigh double the cost of cultivation, without securing to them any adequate equivalent.

It is believed, however, that Ministers will not persist in this part of the plan, and that modification will be proposed that will essentially change its whole character. The scheme of selfredemption must also be given up. The negro, at least, owes do compensation. As to the loan, it may go down with emancipation, but certainly not without it

• It has been observed, “ You cannot object to a loan on West Indian security; for you contend that its value will be improved by emancipation.” I admit that we do so; but it must be emancipaton on our own terms. It must be total and immediate; no longer deferred than till an efficient police can be established. It must not be a partial diluted measure, breaking up one relation of the parties, to substitute another of equal hardship and more difficult operation. This is unsettling one system, which, bad as it is, can work, and replacing it with another, with such a jumble of bad and good, that it becomes inoperative as a stimulus to labour, though it retains the crnel coercive principle. We must not be fixed with an indemnity against a risk essentially different from that which we proposed. It is what the underwriters call a deviation from the policy: of course it discharges our liability'

We could have wished that the zeal of “ Legion ” had been somewhat more tempered by courtesy. Such language and such reasoning as we meet with at pp. 21, 22, are unworthy of the cause, and more adapted to give pain and just offence than to convince. The warmth of the Writer's feelings does him honour, but his judgement should hold a tighter rein.


Mr. Atkinson, of Glasgow, has, we understand, employed the leisure of a lingering illness, during the last winter, in preparing a complete series of the works of The Scottish Poets, with Biographical Notices, after the manner of Dr. Southey and Dr. Aikin's volumes of the Early and more Recent British Poets. It will shortly appear.

A Treatise on Astronomy, by Sir John Herschel, will form the Forty-third Volume of Dr. Lardner's Cabinet Cyclopædia, and will be published on the 1st of June.

Dictionary, Practical, Theoretical, and Historical, of Commerce and Commercial Navigation. By J. R. M'Culloch, Esq. 1 large Vol. 8vo. with Maps. A Second and Improved Edition preparing.

On June the 1st will be published, Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, Green, and Longman's Catalogue of Second-Hand Books for 1833 : comprising a fine Collection of Books of Prints, including many of the Galleries ; Divinity and Ecclesiastical History, Foreign and English ; Valuable Works in various Foreign Languages, and a useful Collection of Works on Topography, History, Biography, Poetry, Voyages, and Travels, &c. &c. &c.

Elements of Musical Composition; comprehending the Rules of Thorough Bass, and the Theory of Tuning. By William Crotch, Mus. Doc. A New Edition, preparing, in small 4to.



Astronomical Observations, made at the Observatory of Cambridge, for the year 1832. By George Biddell Airy, Esq., M.A., Plumian Prof. of Astron., and Exper. Phil., in the University of Cambridge. Royal Quarto. 15s.

EDUCATION. Hints for the Formation and Management of Sunday Schools. By the Rev. J. C. Wigram, M.A., Secretary to the National School Society. 2s.


The Annual Historian for 1833; comprising the Events of the Previous Year, By Ingram Coblin, A.M. 18mo. 3s. cloth.


The Crusaders; or, Scenes, Events, and Characters, from the Times of the Crusades. By Thomas Keightly. With Views, &c. 5s. 6d. Cloth lettered.

Insects and their Habitations, A Book for Children. With many Engravings. ]$.

Persian Fables, for Young and Old. By the Rev. H. G. Keene, M.A. With Eighteen Illustrative Engravings. ls.

A Residence at the Court of London. By the Honourable Richard Rush, Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary to the United States of America, from 1817 to 1825. 8vo. 14s.

Authentic Letters from Upper Canada : with an Account of Canadian Field Sports. By T. W. Magrath, Esq. Edited by the Rev. T. Radcliff; with etchings by Samuel Lover, Esq., R.H.A. 6s.


Readings in Poetry. A Selection from the best English Poets, from Spenser to the Present Time: anu Specimens of several American Poets of deserved reputation : with a History of English Poetry, and an Essay on Versification. Cloth lettered, 4s. 6d.


the Abolition of Colonial Slavery, and containing suggestions of a plan really and satisfactory in its character, 1s.

A Plan for the Reconciliation of all Interests in the Emancipation of West India Slaves. By John Hancock, M.D. 641.

The Book of Rights; or, Constitutional Acts and Parliamentary Proceedings affecting Civil and Religious Liberty in England, from Magna Charta to the present time. Historically arranged, with Notes and Observations. By Edgar Taylor, F.S.A. 6s. 6d. extra cloth buards.

The Interests of the Country, and the Prospects of West Indian Planters, mutually secured by the immediate Abolition of Slavery. By James Cropper. Second edition. Is.

Wages or the Whip. An Essay on the Comparative Cost and Productiveness of Free and Slave Labour. By Josiah Conder. Author of the Modern Traveller,'' &c. &c. Svo. 2s. 6d.

A Vindication of the Loan of £15,000,000 to the West India Planters, showing that it may not only be lent with perfect safety, but with immense advantage both to the West Indians and to the people of England. By James Cropper. 8vo. 6d.

Considerations on Civil Establishments of Religion. By H. Heugh, D.D. 8vo. 2s. 60.

A Critique on Dr. Ralph Wardlaw's Sermon, “ Civil Establishments of Chris. tianity;" showing that it is unfounded in scripture, contradicted by ecclesiastical history, is based on what is not true, and is alike repudiated by sound criticism and conclusive argument.

By Alexander Fleming, A.M., Minister of Neilston.


Christianity Epitomised, with Antithesis analytical and illustrative of the Papacy. Contents :- Israelitish Christianity Christianity typical and psalmodic-Historic Christianity to the close of the first century-- The Atonement-The Personality and Influences of the Holy Spirit - Historic Christianity to the close of the second century- Pagan Philosophy- Progressive Christianity to the Constantine era- The Papacy contrasted with Christianity- Socianism repelled-Trinitarianisin advocated— The attributes of Faith-Justification - Christian identity-Sabbatic desecration, &c. &c. es. cloth boards.

POLITICAL Whom are we to look to? or, Things as they Are. Some brief remarks on the present state of Parties in this country. “ Cui Fidas Videas." Is.

A Letter from Legion to the Right Hon. E. G. Stanley, upon his Scheme for

« ForrigeFortsett »