Section

Page

7. PLEADING BY WAY OF RECITAL, IN THE ALTERNATIVE AND HYPOTHETICALLY.

Thompson v. Read (1909) 63 Misc. (N. Y.) 235....

Malott v. Sample (1904) 164 Ind. 645

327

328

Anderson v. Minneapolis, St. P. & S. Ste. M. Ry. Co. (1908) 103

Minn. 224

332

Hasberg v. Moses (1903) 81 N. Y. App. Div. 199

Emison v. Owyhee Ditch Co. (1900) 37 Ore. 577.

334

337

8. ANTICIPATING DEFENSES.

Western Union Tel. Co. v. Henley (1901) 157 Ind. 90

Royal Ins. Co. v. Schwing (1888) 87 Ky. 41C...

A. L. Clark Lumber Co. v. Johns (1911) 98 Ark. 211.

9. SPECIAL DAMAGES.

338

339

341

Fledderman v. St. Louis Transit Co. (1908) 134 Mo. App. 199 343

Stephens v. Am. Fire Ins. Co. (1896) 14 Utah, 265..

353

CHAPTER V.

THE ANSWER.

1. GENERAL PRINCIPLES.

Strook Plush Co. v. Talcott (1908) 129 N. Y. App. Div. 14...

Jones v. City of Caldwell (1911) 20 Idaho, 5

356

368

Browning, King & Co. v. Terwilliger (1911) 144 N. Y. App. Div.

Prunty v. Consolidated Fuel & Light Co. (1910) 82 Kan. 541..

Cooper v. Am. Cent. Ins. Co. (1909) 139 Mo. App. 570..

Welles v. Colo. Nat. Life Assur. Co. (1911) 49 Colo. 508.

Smith v. Allen (1901) 63 Neb. 74

387

388

(c) Issues Raised by Denials.

Baxter v. St. Louis Transit Co. (1906) 198 Mo. 1........

Wiedeman v. Hedges (1901) 63 Neb. 103

Wilson v. Charleston & Savannah Ry. (1897) 51 S. C. 79.

Duff v. Willamette Steel Works (1904) 45 Ore. 479..

390

394

395

399

Multnomah County v. Willamette Towing Co. (1907) 49 Ore. 204 402

Jones v. El Reno Mill & Elevator Co. (1910) 26 Okla. 796.....

Section

3. AFFIRMAtive DefenSES.

Jacoby v. James (1910) 136 N. Y. App., Div. 431

Cincinnati Traction Co. v. Forrest (1905) 73 Ohio St. 1.

Ramp v. Metropolitan St. Ry. Co. (1908) 133 Mo. App. 700...

Libby v. St. Louis, Iron Mt. & So. Ry. Co. (1909) 137 Mo. App.
276

State Savings Bank v. Albertson (1909) 39 Mont. 414..

Penn. Mut. Life Ins. Co. v. Ornauer (1907) 39 Colo. 498....

Columbia Nat. Bank v. Western Iron & Steel Co. (1896) 14

Wash. 162.

Page

416

417

419

420

423

425

427

429

432

Vallancey v. Hunt (1910) 20 N. D. 579..

Thompson v. Halbert (1888) 109 N. Y. 329

4. INCONSISTENT DEFENSES.

Banta v. Siller (1898) 121 Cal. 414

Seattle Nat. Bank v. Carter (1895) 13 Wash. 281.

Loveland v. Jenkins-Boys Co. (1908) 49 Wash. 369.

436

438

442

445

448

450

454

5. ANSWERS IN ABATEMENT.

Needham v. Wright (1895) 140 Ind. 190

455

Callahan Co. v. Wall Rice Milling Co. (1909) 44 Ind. App. 372 457

McKim v. District Court (1910) 33 Nev. 44

459

6. COUNTERCLAIMS.

(a) General Nature.

General Electric Co. v. Williams (1898) 123 N. C. 51.

State v. Arkansas Brick & Mfg. Co. (1911) 98 Ark. 125.

Walker v. Am. Cent. Ins. Co. (1894) 143 N. Y. 167.

Shelton v. Conant (1894) 10 Wash. 193

461

463

466

469

470

473

Stoner v. Swift (1904) 164 Ind. 652

Nat. Fire Ins. Co. v. McKay (1860) 21 N. Y. 191.

Adams v. Schwartz (1910) 137 N. Y. App. Div. 230

478

(2) Connected with the Subject of the Action.

Wild Rice Lumber Co. v. Benson (1911) 114 Minn. 92.......

487

(3) In an Action on Contract, any Other on Contract.

Jansen v. Dolan (1911) 157 Mo. App. 32

Rooker v. Bruce (1909) 45 Ind. App. 57

490

493

(d) Parties to Counterclaims.

Weeks v. O'Brien (1898) 25 N. Y. App. Div. 206

494

Pope Mfg. Co. v. Charleston Cycle Co. (1898) 55 S. C. 528.... 496

(e) Jurisdictional Amount.

General Electric Co. v. Williams (1898) 123 N. C. 51.

498

Howard Iron Works v. Buffalo Elevating Co. (1903) 176 N. Y. 1 500

(f) Existence at Commencement of Action.

Smith v. French (1906) 141 N. C. 1...

505

(g) Election between Counter claim and Independent Action.

Jones v. Witousek & Co. (1901) 114 Iowa, 14...

508

Section

(h) Effect of Assignment on Right to Counterclaim.

Stadler v. First Nat. Bank of Helena (1898) 22 Mont. 190....
St. Louis Nat. Bank v. Gay (1894) 101 Cal. 286..

Page

511

521

526

Kollock v. Scribner (1897) 98 Wis. 104.....

529

McCall Co. v. Stone (1905) 124 Wis. 572

551

Fidelity & Deposit Co. v. Parkinson (1903) 68 Neb. 319.

Sprunt v. Gordon (1911) 89 S. C. 426

552

553

Jeffries v. Fraternal Bankers' Reserve Society (1907) 135

Iowa, 284

Downey v. Colo. Fuel & Iron Co. (1910) 48 Colo. 27

Rice v. Rice (1886) 13 Ore. 337

560

561

Heaton v. Packer (1909) 131 N. Y. App. Div. 812

Mallinckrodt Chemical Works v. Nemnich (1902) 169 Mo. 388..

Sprague v. New York & N. E. Rd. Co. (1896) 68 Conn. 345.... 570

565

566

(c) Searching the Record.

Baxter v. McDonnell (1897) 154 N. Y. 432

571

Callahan v. Louisville Dry Goods Co. (1910) 140 Ky. 712.

Baldwin v. City of Aberdeen (1909) 23 S. D. 636

572

574

Fulton County Gas & Elec. Co. v. Hudson River Teleph. Co.

(1911) 200 N. Y. 287

Calif. Safe Dep. & Trust Co. v. Sierra Valleys Ry. Co. (1910)

158 Cal. 690

582

Fitger Brewing Co. v. Am. Bonding Co. (1911) 115 Minn. 78..

Kleinclaus v. Dutard (1905) 147 Cal. 245.

East St. Louis Ice Co. v. Kuhlmann (1911) 238 Mo. 685...... 589

Belden v. Wilkinson (1899) 44 N. Y. App. Div. 420....

Peterson v. Pantheon Lumber Co. (1911) 62 Wash. 189.

591

593

Section

4. WANT OF LEGAL CAPACITY TO SUE.

Page

Coddington v. Canaday (1901) 157 Ind. 243.

Los Angeles Ry Co. v. Davis (1905) 146 Cal. 179.

595

597

Page Woven Wire Fence Co. v. Joslin (1906) 38 Colo. 162.

601

5. ANOTHER ACTION PENDING.

Wetzstein v. Boston & Mont. Consol. Copper etc., Co.

(1903) 28 Mont. 451.

602

Kurtz v. Ogden Canyon Sanitarium Co. (1910) 37 Utah, 313... 617

Howe v. Coates (1903) 90 Minn. 508....

618

Rand v. Butte Elec. Ry Co. (1909) 40 Mont. 398...

624

St. Louis, I. M. & So. Ry. Co. v. Higgins (1884) 44 Ark. 293.. 627

Stenson v. Elfmann (1910) 26 S. D. 134.

628

Tate v. Rose (1909) 35 Utah, 229....

629

Sterling v. Smith (1893) 97 Cal. 343.

633

2. DEPARTURE.

Hill Brick & Tile Co. v. Gibson (1908) 43 Colo. 104..

Spiess' Adm'x v. Bartley (1908) 130 Ky, 277...

Johnson v. State Bank of Seneca (1898) 59 Kan. 250.

Brown v. Baker (1901) 39 Ore. 66..

636

637

639

640

St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co. v. Mountain Park Stock

Farm Co. (1909) 23 Okla. 79.

642

3. COUNTERCLAIM IN REPLY.

Beakey v. Vander Meerschen (1908) 78 Kan. 538......

645

4. WAIVER OF REPLY.

Merchants' Nat. Bank v. Barlow (1900) 79 Minn. 234........ 647

CHAPTER VIII.

MOTIONS

1. IN GENERAL.

Wallace v. Lewis (1890) 9 Mont. 399..

650

2. MOTION TO STRIKE.

Tittle v. Kennedy (1904) 71 S. C. 1....

Ewing v. Vernon County (1908) 216 Mo. 681.

Blemel v. Shattuck (1892) 133 Ind. 498.

Swank v. Elwert (1910) 55 Ore. 487..

655

656

657

659

3. MOTION TO MAKE MORE DEFINITE AND CERTAIN.

Casey v. Dorr (1910) 94 Ark. 433..

Grimes v. Cullison (1895) 3 Okla. 268.

668

669

Blair v. Wilkeson Coal & Coke Co. (1909) 54 Wash. 334.

Cornell v. Haight (1910) 87 Neb. 508...

Commonwealth Co. v. Nunn (1902) 17 Colo. App. 117.

Pugh v. Winona & St. Peter Rd. Co. (1882) 29 Minn. 390..

670

671

672

674

4. MOTION TO ELECT,

Darknell v. Coeur D'Alene & St. Joe Transp. Co. (1910) 18

Idaho 61

676

Le Breton v. Stanley Contracting Co. (1911) 15 Cal. App. 429

Thomas v. Ray (1910) 48 Colo. 423....

677

680

Board of Commissioners v. Am. Loan & Trust Co. (1899) 75

Minn. 489

689

Pratt, Hurst & Co. v. Tailer (1904) 99 N. Y. App. Div. 236.

Abbott v. Meinken (1900) 48 N. Y. Div. 109..

695

696

2. DILIGENCE OF PARTY Seeking Amendment.

Paulsen v. Modern Woodmen (1911) 21 N. D. 235....

698

Heiden v. Atlantic Coast Line R. R. Co. (1909) 84 S. C. 117..

Home Ins. Co. v. Overturf (1904) 35 Ind. App. 361....

699

701

3. SHOWING OF PREJUDICE BY PARTY OPPOSING AMENDMENT.

Bowers v. Good (1909) 52 Wash. 384..

Flaherty v. Butte Elec. Ry. Co. (1911) 43 Mont. 141.

718