into divisions or things, fides, and mizmaze, &c.' The omiffion was owing to mere ignorance and ofcitancy on our parts; and not, as the Author seems to suspect, to our joining in the general dread and alarm whick, it seems, has seized our Gram, marians and Lexicographers,' our · Booksellers' and our • Seminaries,' left these his most momentous discoveries ' peuld overturn the present lyftems of things.'

[ocr errors]


ART. XIII. An Esay on the Nature and Circulation of the Blood, in

Two Parts. 1. On its. Nature and Uses. | An its Circulation,

By Marmaduke Berdoe, M. D. 8vo. Is. 6 d. Robinson. 1772. Art. XIV. Theory of the Human Sensations. By Marmaduke Berdoe, M.D. 8vo.

Lowndes. 1773•
R. Berdoe writes fo frequently, and on so many subje&ts,

that he muft excuse us for taking the liberty of lumping his two tracis together; elpecially as we actually find ourselves unqualified to give any clear, distinct, or confiftent account of their contents. We really can seldom discover what he would be at; and, though conversant in his writings, are still in a great measure ignorant of the language in which he wraps up his new and mysterious doctrines. We are utterly unacquainted, for instance, with the animating atherial clince,' which, he tells us, the arteries canvey ' in mucuai ft:eams to the different organs ;' though we have read and studied his explanatory note on this passage, in which he informs us that the ætherial iffence means the fixed air, or the air, or acrial particles contained in the blood," which is supposed to be the same with what is called elementary fire.' This note, however, conveys to us no other information than what we were already poffefled of; that the Doctor has an excellent knack at playing off a set of newfangled phrases, of dealing out his alber plentifully, and of jumbling the elements together by a dash or two of his pen.

We have indeed, by this time, learnt that his ' exterior organ' a grand and active agent in the Doctor's physiology, is neither more nor less than what we and others simply call the skin ;but as to his phrenic centers: —hiscenters, and his points, of appuy'—which are continually occurring in the second of these tracts,—and his disgregations in the organical forces—together with many other choice and recondite terms and phrases--they furpass our comprehenfion nearly as much as his brother Jones's

quaternion of elements,' or his burning bush in strait lines, expanding an infinite circle in a triad,' recorded in the preceding article. All these phrases, we doubt not, have ideas tacked to them, in the congenial heads of these two writers: but though Dr. Berdoe's exterior organi' ' mucual streams,' and 'disgregamons,' doubtless ferve many important purposes in his Theory of Human Sensations ; an account of them, or of their mystic agency


and powers *, cannot be expected from our sober and unenlightened pens.

And yet these and the Author's former and future publications, it seems, contain a System that will speedily astonith the world, by its ftupendous magnitude and power. In the concluding paragraph of the first of these two tracts, the fond fa. ther off it accuses us of having exerted our weak endeavours en Nište this young Hercules in its cradle ; and gives us fair warning to make quick dispatch, if we expect to succeed in our de. sperate attempt to check the rapid growth of this strapping youngster.—Hear what the Doctor himself fays on the subje&t. Our representation might, perhaps, be thought exaggerated :

· These opinions,' says he, will be confirmed by future publications, particularly by an Enquiry into the Nature of the Human Pulse, and the Motion of the Arteries. But if the Reviewers are determined to destroy Our System in the bud, they Mould not lose the present opportunity, as by length of time it may grow into so powerful a Colossus, as to bid defiance at last' to all the artillery of their genius.'

We appeal, on this occasion, to the judgiment of the impartial Public; not doubting but they will acquit us of the dark design here imputed to us by this unaccountable mortal. We have indeed more than once dislented from the Doctor's opinions, when we have understood them; and in particular acknowledge that, in March 1773, justly provoked to see the rays of light violently twisted and joftled out of their natural and lawful course by this bold innovator, we stoutly defended the good old laws of vision, against the Doctor's New System of seeing :—but from dates and other circumstances, it is evident that this cannot be the growing Colossus above referred to t.

It was well judged in the Doctor to give the skin, that humble covering of the body, the high sounding title above mentioned. The phrenic centers, and even the brain, it seems,. yield in power to the • exterior organ'

+ The Doctor breeds so fast, and brings forth so many new syftems and theories, that we proteit we have overlooked a capital one indeede promulgated in this very essay. Here, if we rightly compushed him, he demolishes the old Harveian circulation,-dethrones the heart-and portions out its hitherto undisputed, aniversal dominion over the circulating fluids, into numerous principalities, under the government of the spongiform fubftance of the cellulary-membrane, dispersed over the various parts of the body. These heptarchies, (though we know not their precise number) are the principal agents in the circulation, and each part of the body has a circulation pea culiar to itself.'-Where will this man stop!-If he be suffered to go on long at this violent rate, we must e'en shut our books, and all go to school again :-a mortifying step, to be obliged to take at our It appears, however, that by our rough treatment of the new optical system, we had nearly, though unwittingly, deprived the world of the present new Theory of the Human Senfations, We will recite the alarming tale in the Doctor's own words.

Every thing, it seems, was prepared for the promulgation of the new theory, when a friend brought him the Monthly Review for March 1773, to let him see how severely he had been criticised, by the learned body of the Monthly Reviewers.'

· Tortured and vexed, I was going to throw all this theory into the fire, if it had not occurred to me, that two heads are of. tentimes better than one.--Pleased with the thought, I called up my cookmaid, and bid her run her eye very carefully over the whole.'-(the very identical eye, we fufpect, in which the Doctor saw the erect image~See the aforesaid Review, page 238, where he slyly calls it the eye of a friend) She liked it, and approved of my publifhing.'

• Under the fanction then of her great authority I boldly venture once more to request your great decision: I Hatter myself I shall please you, for though my cookmard is not so learned as a Reviewer, she is as excellent an old woman as the best

What could induce this wench to relish the Doctor's theory, where he principally derives our pleasurable and other sensations from the Midrif, is best known to berself.But are these, Dr. Berdoe, your clinical and practical observations, that you promited us when you commenced Author t? Viewing yourself in your cookmaid's pupiland communing with her on the true feat of pleasurable sensations ? Fie upon you !--By way of screen, you would pass her off to us and the world for an old woman, like ourselves. ---But a set of elderly matrons, as we are, are not to be so taken in. She is a young wanton baggage, we'll warrant her, and no better than she thould be.

+ See M. Review, vol. xlvi. April 1772, p. 443.

I These, says the Doctor, p. 35, are produced by all those causes that' forcibly enchain as in the polslon of those objects which may be called the idols of human happiness.? Here we have the fair sex plainly designed. She liked it,' fays the Doctor. They are his very words. See above.


[ocr errors]

Art. XV. Chirurgical Observations and Cafes. By William Brom

field, Surgeon to her Majesty, and to St. George's Hospital. Illustrated with Copper-plates. 8vo. 2 Vols. 145. Cadell. 1773.

ANY new, pertinent, and useful remarks are contained

in this work, which is however unnecessarily enlarged by a confiderable number of trite and insignificant observations, that seem to answer no other purpose than that of swelling the matter, which might with ease have been contained in one vo



lume, into two, The Author seems to have entertained the same apprehensions with Martial, that his works would be in danger of being lost, were they not eked out, and expanded into a larger bulk, by the addition of supplementary materials, no matter of what quality :

Edita ne brevibus pereat mihi charta libellis,
• Dicatur potius τον δ' απαμειβομενος.'

De Libro Suo Lib. i. Epigr. 46. The disposition of this matter likewise is frequently such as to incline the Reader to suppose that the Author had emptied his whole common-place book, and given its heterogeneous contents to the Public, just as the different articles stood there; without fele&tion, and with very little regard to form, language, or method. Of this inexcusable inattention to order we shall give the two following very striking instances.

In the ad chapter of his first volume, where the Author in the title of it profesies to treat of Amputation, the Reader will, at the beginning of it, meet with an enumeration of some of the complaints that seem to indicate, or that require, the removal of a limb. From this subject however he will soon find him fliding away to another, that bears indeed some affinity to the operation ;--the nature, causes, and signs of a mortification, He now begins to lose sight of the original object, for he must next accompany the Author starting into the doctrine of inflammation ; discussing the various theories that have been formed on that subject, and finally propofing his own opinion. Having got over this litigated matter, the Author next treats of perspiration. He then proceeds to the sea and the land scurvy; and from thence to the pox, where he gives us his sentiments on the powers of corrosive sublimate in venereal complaints. From thence he leads the Reader to Harwich, and treats of seabathing, and the utility of warm fea-baths, first proposed by himself about fifteen years ago. Returning once more to inflammation he sticks to it pretty closely, to the end of the chapter;-like Montaigne and Tristram Shandy, leaving his companion at leisure to look about him, at the end of it, for the subject he first set off with. After a pause, the reader proceeds to chap. 3, where he finds him treating of Tumours ; in chap. 4, of the Erysipelas ; in chap. 5, of the Anthrax or Carbuncle. Here, and under this unpromising title, he at length unexpectedly meets with a large number of observations or remarks, some of them new and important, on the subject of amputation; particularly on that of the arm at the articulation of the shoulder.

The next instance of the neglect of order in this work, presents us likewise with a fingular example of the want of a good understanding or correspondence between its different parts. In chap. 4, of the 2d volume, On Fractures,' we were surprised


not to find our Author keeping pace at least with his cotempo. raries, in the fimple and efficacious improvements that have been lately introduced into that branch of practice *. At page 59, indeed, we have one tranfient glimpse afforded us, in about four words, of a part of the new treatment; where in the case of a considerable tumefaction of the limb, preventing its reduction, we are told that while the surgeon is using means to bring down the swelling, as well as afterwards when he attempts the reduction of the broken bone, if the fracture is of the tibia or fibula,

the knee sbould be bent.' But throughout the rest of this chapter, scarce a veftige of the improved practice is to be traced : on the contrary, we find the Author itill retaining the use of plaisters, the endless circumvolutions of a long lingle-headed roller, and the leg box ;-parts of the inconvenient and noxious trumpery of our forefathers.

Proceeding onwards however to chap. 7, we are again, equally, furprised to find our Author there not only warmly recommending the placing the fractured leg, for instance, in a bent polition, in order to relax the suscles, both in the case of simple and of compound fractures, and not only during but after reduction ;-suffering the patient to lie at his eale, on his fide or otherwise, with his leg unconfined, on a soft pillow ;-and Itrongly approving the use of the eighteen-tailed bandage, on account of its evident advantages above the circular :—but we find him likewise putting in his claim to a considerable {hare in the discovery of these late improvements, and contending that it is now near 30 years since he first recommended and inculcated them to his auditors, in his public lectures. This claim we thall not contravert ; but it is fingular, and certainly favours our idea of the Author's having huddled together the materials of the present work from his old and new common place books; to find him observing nearly a total silence with respect to certain modern improvements, in a part of his work where he is profefsedly treating of the subject to which they immediately relate : while in another part of it, he insists on the great advantages derived from them, and contends for the honour of having long ago inculcated them.

Though the titles of the chapters into which this work is divided, do not, as the Reader already perceives, eyery where accurately specify their contents; we shall enumerate them, in order to give the Reader some information concerning the subjects that are greated of in these two volumes.

The firit is divided into fix chapters. In the first, which has no title, the Author, on too flight grounds, in our opinion, re

[ocr errors]

* We have formerly given a popular account of these improvements, and their rationale, in our 40th volume, June 1769, p. 465.



« ForrigeFortsett »