UNITED STATES

CIRCUIT COURTS OF APPEALS

REPORTS

850

June 7

с

WITH ANNOTATIONS

WITH TABLE OF CASES IN THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURTS
OF APPEALS WHICH HAVE BEEN PASSED UPON BY THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

133-154 F

VOLUME 83

LAWYERS' CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING CO.

ROCHESTER

1908

COPYRIGHT, 1908,

83 C.C.A.

BY

LAWYERS' CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING CO.

MAR 5

1908

JUDGES

OF THE

UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURTS OF APPEALS AND THE CIRCUIT AND DISTRICT COURTS.

FIRST CIRCUIT.

Hon. OLIVER WENDELL HOLMES, Circuit Justice..
Hon. LE BARON B. COLT, Circuit Judge.......
Hon. WILLIAM L. PUTNAM, Circuit Judge...
Hon. FRANCIS C. LOWELL, Circuit Judge......
Hon. CLARENCE HALE, District Judge, Maine....
Hon. FREDERIC DODGE, District Judge, Massachusetts.
Hon. EDGAR ALDRICH, District Judge, New Hampshire..
Hon. ARTHUR L. BROWN, District Judge, Rhode Island..

SECOND CIRCUIT.

Hon. RUFUS W. PECKHAM, Circuit Justice..
Hon. E. HENRY LACOMBE, Circuit Judge.
Hon. ALFRED C. COXE, Circuit Judge..
Hon. HENRY G. WARD, Circuit Judge..
Hon. WALTER C. NOYES, Circuit Judge 1..

Hon. JAMES P. PLATT, District Judge, Connecticut.....
Hon. THOMAS I. CHATFIELD, District Judge, E. D. New
Hon. GEORGE W. RAY, District Judge, N. D. New York....
Hon. GEORGE B. ADAMS, District Judge, S. D. New York..
Hon. GEORGE C. HOLT, District Judge, S. D. New York......
Hon. CHARLES M. HOUGH, District Judge, S. D. New York..
Hon. JOHN R. HAZEL, District Judge, W. D. New York.....
Hon. JAMES L. MARTIN, District Judge, Vermont......

1 Appointed September 18, 1907. 83 C.C.A.

THIRD CIRCUIT.

Hon. WILLIAM H. MOODY, Circuit Justice..
Hon. GEORGE M. DALLAS, Circuit Judge..
Hon. GEORGE GRAY, Circuit Judge....
Hon. JOSEPH BUFFINGTON, Circuit Judge..

Hon. EDWARD G. BRADFORD, District Judge, Delaware.
Hon. WILLIAM M. LANNING, District Judge, New Jersey..
Hon. JOSEPH CROSS, District Judge, New Jersey.....

(iii)

Washington, D. C.
.New York, N. Y.

.Utica, N. Y.
.New York, N. Y.
.New London, Conn.
..Hartford, Conn.
York...........Brooklyn, N. Y.
.......Norwich, N. Y

........

.New York, N. Y.
.New York, N. Y.
New York, N. Y.

.Buffalo, N. Y.
.Brattleboro, Vt.

......

.Washington, D. C.
.Providence, R. I.
.. Portland, Me.
.Boston, Mass.
..Portland, Me.
..Boston, Mass.
.Littleton, N. H.
.Providence, R. I.

Washington, D. C.
.Philadelphia, Pa.
Wilmington, Del.

.Pittsburgh, Pa. ....Wilmington, Del. ......Trenton, N. J. ...Elizabeth, N. J.

.Philadelphia, Pa.
.Philadelphia, Pa.

Hon. JOHN B. MCPHERSON, District Judge, E. D. Pennsylvania.....
Hon. JAMES B. HOLLAND, District Judge, E. D. Pennsylvania..
Hon. ROBERT WODROW ARCHBALD, District Judge, M. D. Pennsylvania.. Scranton, Pa.
Hon. NATHANIEL EWING, District Judge, W. D. Pennsylvania... ........Pittsburgh, Pa.

FOURTH CIRCUIT.

Hon. MELVILLE W. FULLER, Circuit Justice..

Hon. NATHAN GOFF, Circuit Judge...

Hon. JETER C. PRITCHARD, Circuit Judge..

Hon. THOMAS J. MORRIS, District Judge, Maryland..

..Raleigh, N. C.
.Greensboro, N. C.

Hon. THOMAS R. PURNELL, District Judge, E. D. North Carolina.
Hon. JAMES E. BOYD, District Judge, W. D. North Carolina....
Hon. WILLIAM H. BRAWLEY, District Judge, E. and W. D. South Car..Charleston, S. C.
Hon. EDMUND WADDILL, Jr., District Judge, E. D. Virginia.
Hon. HENRY CLAY MCDOWELL, District Judge, W. D. Virginia...
Hon. ALSTON G. DAYTON, District Judge, N. D. West Virginia..
Hon. BENJAMIN F. KELLER, District Judge, S. D. West Virginia..
......Bramwell, W. Va.

..Richmond, Va.
...Lynchburg, Va.
.Philippi, W. Va.

FIFTH CIRCUIT.

2 Died July 5, 1907.

.Washington, D. C.
.Clarksburg, W. Va.
.Asheville, N. C.
....Baltimore, Md.

Hon. EDWARD D. WHITE, Circuit Justice....
Hon. DON A. PARDEE, Circuit Judge...

Hon. A. P. McCORMICK, Circuit Judge..
Hon. DAVID D. SHELBY, Circuit Judge..
Hon. THOMAS G. JONES, District Judge, N. and M. D. Alabama.
Hon. OSCAR R. HUNDLEY, District Judge, N. D. Alabama..
Hon. HARRY T. TOULMIN, District Judge, S. D. Alabama.
Hon. CHARLES SWAYNE, District Judge, N. D. Florida ".
Hon. WM. B. SHEPPARD, District Judge, N. D. Florida 3.
Hon. JAMES W. LOCKE, District Judge, S. D. Florida..
Hon. WILLIAM T. NEWMAN, District Judge, N. D. Georgia.
Hon. EMORY SPEER, District Judge, S. D. Georgia....
Hon. EUGENE D. SAUNDERS, District Judge, E. D. Louisiana.
Hon. ALECK BOARMAN, District Judge, W. D. Louisiana..
Hon. HENRY C. NILES, District Judge, N. and S. D. Mississippi.
Hon. DAVID E. BRYANT, District Judge, E. D. Texas..
Hon. EDWARD R. MEEK, District Judge, N. D. Texas..
Hon. WALLER T. BURNS, District Judge, S. D. Texas.
Hon. THOMAS S. MAXEY, District Judge, W. D. Texas..

.Washington, D. C.
.Atlanta, Ga.
..Dallas, Tex.
.Huntsville, Ala.
Montgomery, Ala.
.Birmingham, Ala.
.......Mobile, Ala.
.Pensacola, Fla.
.Pensacola, Fla.
.Jacksonville, Fla.

...Atlanta, Ga.
..Macon, Ga.
.New Orleans, La.

.Shreveport, La.
.Kosciusko, Miss.
.Sherman, Tex.
..Dallas, Tex.
..Houston, Tex.
..Austin, Tex.

SIXTH CIRCUIT.

Hon. JOHN M. HARLAN, Circuit Justice.
Hon. HORACE H. LURTON, Circuit Judge..
Hon. HENRY F. SEVERENS, Circuit Judge.
Hon. JOHN K. RICHARDS, Circuit Judge.
Hon. ANDREW M. J. COCHRAN, District Judge, E. D. Kentucky.
Hon. WALTER EVANS, District Judge, W. D. Kentucky..
Hon. HENRY H. SWAN, District Judge, E. D. Michigan...
Hon. LOYAL E. KNAPPEN, District Judge, W. D. Michigan.
Hon. ROBERT W. TAYLER, District Judge, N. D. Ohio.....
Hon. ALBERT C. THOMPSON, District Judge, S. D. Ohio..
Hon. JOHN E. SATER, District Judge, S. D. Ohio....
Hon. CHARLES D. CLARK, District Judge, E. and M. D. Tennessee....Chattanooga, Tenn.
Hon. JOHN E. McCALL, District Judge, W. D. Tennessee...................

.Memphis, Tenn.

.Washington, D. C.

.Nashville, Tenn. .Kalamazoo, Mich. ...Cincinnati, Ohio.

.Maysville, Ky.
.Louisville, Ky.

..Detroit, Mich.

..Grand Rapids, Mich.
......Cleveland, Ohio.
....Cincinnati, Ohio.
.Columbus, Ohio.

Appointed September 4, 1907.

SEVENTH CIRCUIT.

Hon. WILLIAM R. DAY, Circuit Justice.....
Hon. PETER S. GROSSCUP, Circuit Judge........
Hon. FRANCIS E. BAKER, Circuit Judge....
Hon. WILLIAM H. SEAMAN, Circuit Judge....
Hon. CHRISTIAN C. KOHLSAAT, Circuit Judge....

Hon. KENESAW M. LANDIS, District Judge, N. D. Illinois.
Hon. SOLOMON H. BETHEA, District Judge, N. D. Illinois.
Hon. FRANCIS M. WRIGHT, District Judge, E. D. Illinois.
Hon. J. OTIS HUMPHREY, District Judge, S. D. Illinois.....
Hon. ALBERT B. ANDERSON, District Judge, Indiana....
Hon. JOSEPH V. QUARLES, District Judge, E. D. Wisconsin..
Hon. ARTHUR L. SANBORN, District Judge, W. D. Wisconsin..

EIGHTH CIRCUIT.

Hon. DAVID J. BREWER, Circuit Justice....
Hon. WALTER H. SANBORN, Circuit Judge..
Hon. WILLIS VAN DEVANTER, Circuit Judge.
Hon. WILLIAM C. HOOK, Circuit Judge.....
Hon. ELMER B. ADAMS, Circuit Judge..

Hon. JACOB TRIEBER, District Judge, E. D. Arkansas.
Hon. JOHN H. ROGERS, District Judge, W. D. Arkansas..
Hon. ROBERT E. LEWIS, District Judge, Colorado.
Hon. HENRY THOMAS REED, District Judge, N. D. Iowa.
Hon. SMITH MCPHERSON, District Judge, S. D. Iowa...
Hon. JOHN C. POLLOCK, District Judge, Kansas..
Hon. WM. LOCHREN, District Judge, Minnesota......
Hon. PAGE MORRIS, District Judge, Minnesota.....
Hon. DAVID P. DYER, District Judge, E. D. Missouri..
Hon. JOHN F. PHILIPS, District Judge, W. D. Missouri.
Hon. W. H. MUNGER, District Judge, Nebraska....
Hon. THOMAS C. MUNGER, District Judge, Nebraska..
Hon. CHARLES F. AMIDON, District Judge, North Dakota..
Hon. JOHN E. CARLAND, District Judge, South Dakota.......
Hon. JOHN A. MARSHALL, District Judge, Utah..............................
Hon. JOHN A. RINER, District Judge, Wyoming....

.......

NINTH CIRCUIT.

.Washington, D. C.
...Chicago, Ill.
..Indianapolis, Ind.
..Sheboygan, Wis.

.Washington, D. C. .......St. Paul, Minn. ....Cheyenne, Wyo. .Leavenworth, Kan.

..St. Louis, Mo. .Little Rock, Ark. ........Ft. Smith, Ark. .Denver, Colo. .......Cresco, Iowa. ..Red Oak, Iowa

.Topeka, Kan. .Minneapolis, Minn.

..Duluth, Minn. ....St. Louis, Mo. .Kansas City, Mo.

.Omaha, Neb. ..Lincoln, Neb. .Fargo, N. D. ..Sioux Falls, S. D. ......Salt Lake City, Utah. ...........Cheyenne, Wyo.

..Chicago, Ill. ...Chicago, Ill. ...Chicago, Ill. .....Urbana, Ill. .Springfield, Ill. ..Indianapolis, Ind. .Milwaukee, Wis. .Madison, Wis.

.Washington, D. C. .. Portland, Or. .San Francisco, Cal. ..Los Angeles, Cal. San Francisco, Cal. .San Francisco, Cal.

......Los Angeles, Cal.

Hon. JOSEPH MCKENNA, Circuit Justice....
Hon. WILLIAM B. GILBERT, Circuit Judge..
Hon. WM. W. MORROW, Circuit Judge.....

Hon. ERSKINE M. ROSS, Circuit Judge..

Hon. WM. C. VAN FLEET, District Judge, N. D. California.
Hon. JOHN J. DE HAVEN, District Judge, N. D. California......
Hon. OLIN WELLBORN, District Judge, S. D. California........
Hon. FRANK S. DEITRICH, District Judge, Idaho...
Hon. WILLIAM H. HUNT, District Judge, Montana....
Hon. EDWARD S. FARRINGTON, District Judge, Nevada.....
Hon. CHARLES E. WOLVERTON, District Judge, Oregon..........
Hon. EDWARD WHITSON, District Judge, E. D. Washington... ............................Spokane, Wash.
Hon. CORNELIUS H. HANFORD, District Judge, W. D. Washington.........Seattle, Wash.

.Boise, Idaho,
.Helena, Mont.
.Carson City, Nev.
....... Portland, Or.