 | Joel Prentiss Bishop - 1881 - 786 sider
...exercising a sound and sober judgment on circumstances that are duly proved," judge of them.2 Again: "The only general rule that can be laid down upon...discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion ; 3 for it is not to lead a harsh and intemperate judgment, moving upon appearances that are equally... | |
 | California. Supreme Court - 1882 - 796 sider
...the fact is inferred from circumstances that lead to it by fair inference as a necessary conclusion; and, unless this were so held, no protection whatever...discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion. * * * The facts are not of a technical nature ; Argument for Respondent. they are facts determinable... | |
 | John Bouvier - 1882 - 812 sider
...must be such as would induce the guarded discretion of a just man to the conclusion ; for it must not lead a rash and intemperate judgment moving upon appearances that are equally capable of two 89 Okeson v. Patterson, 29 Penn. St. 22. 81 Comyn, Dig. Action upon Statute, A, F ; Pleader, 2 S, l... | |
 | 1922 - 1148 sider
...circumstantial evidence to prove adultery stated. For circumstantial evidence of adultery to warrant divorce, the circumstances must be such as would lead the guarded discretion of a just mind to the conclusion of the truth of the facts, and, when combined, the circumstances must tend... | |
 | India, Matthew Henry Starling - 1886 - 684 sider
...and insignificant in themselves, but which may have most important bearings upon the particular case. The only general rule that can be laid down upon the...discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion that the offence has been committed; Loveden v. Loveden, 2 Hagg. Con. 2; Stone v. Stone, 1 Robert,... | |
 | Wisconsin. Supreme Court, Abram Daniel Smith, Philip Loring Spooner, Obadiah Milton Conover, Frederic King Conover, Frederick William Arthur, Frederick C. Seibold - 1886 - 762 sider
...Eng. Kcc. 461, to the effect that, to justify a finding that the crime charged has been committed, " the circumstances must be such as would lead the guarded...discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion." These rules received the approval of Chief Justice DIXON in Freeman v. freeman, supra. But whether... | |
 | 1889 - 956 sider
...CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE. To establish adultery by inference, the circumstances from which the inference is drawn must be such as would lead the guarded discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion of guilt. 4. SAME. If the circumstance!! in proof, taken singly and together, admit of two interpretations,... | |
 | 1921 - 958 sider
...court was that— "To prove adultery by circumstantial evidence the circumstances must be such as to lead the guarded discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion of guilt." This is the law. [2, 3] The conclusion adopted was Lord Stowell's often approved of rule... | |
 | 1902 - 1164 sider
...admissible as evidence of the crime. The fact is inferred from circumstances, but they must be such as will lead the guarded discretion of a reasonable and Just man to the conclusion that the offense has been committed. While the respondent is not to be presumed guilty of the crime... | |
 | 1886 - 956 sider
...great part of the testimony, the result is that, in my opinion, the circumstances are not such as to lead the guarded discretion of a. reasonable and just man to the conviction that the act charged was committed. It will not do to base a decree in such a case upon... | |
| |
The only general rule that can be laid down upon the subject is that the circumstances must be such as would lead the guarded discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion... 
